Letters & Opinion

The Pathogens of Deception

Image of Melanius Alphonse
By Melanius Alphonse

STUNNED by the historic sentence of time served (four years on remand) to French national Eric Sommer on a guilty plea of “voluntary manslaughter” to causing the death of Lucas Francois, a Saint Lucian national, at Pigeon Island on May 12, 2012, citizens are up in arms.

Inmates on remand at Bordelais Correctional Facility are deliberating how much more torture to expect from a dysfunctional justice system and the deafening appeal to persons responsible for the legislative and judicial arms of the state.

The odds are that the revolving door of the justice system has created a socio-economic prison, beginning with the epistemic arrogance of Prime Minister Kenny Anthony’s administration.

Recent events are more profound to the intellectual dishonesty that has the propensity to say one thing and do another. What is more striking is the lack of engagement and soul-searching to the obsession with false promises, denial about the happy face of socio economic deprivation and the root cause of injustice.

In my article When Toddlers Rule I wrote: “The circumstances surrounding IMPACS seemingly has met that threshold. But more importantly, this matter looms large on the economic front and on Saint Lucia as a sovereign state. Viewing the EU diplomatic corps press conference earlier this month [January 14, 2016] that schooled Prime Minister Kenny Anthony concerning foreign policy goals, national security provisions and objectives gave the impression of the resumption to colonial rule”.

At that press conference, Saint Lucia based French ambassador Eric de La Moussaye, complained about this country’s broken justice system and the plight of six Frenchmen at the Bordelais Correctional Facility, particularly Eric Sommer.

What is more demonstrable is “diplomatic justice” and the notion that perhaps represents trade-offs on future operations that remain shrouded in secrecy, resulting from Saint Lucia’s distressing issues confronting IMPACS and US action in the Caribbean.

Hence, acting on the prevailing conditions that influence vulnerability, the French walked right through open doors. The rationale is epistemic humility doubled down on Prime Minister Anthony and his useless administrative model of epistemic arrogance.

The other dynamic that may have arisen is “opportunity cost” on border security. Or, was it mere coincidence that the recent narco-trafficking operation was appropriate to foreign authorities’ military assets?

Prime Minister Anthony has often underscored the executive’s separation from the legislative and the judicial arms of the state: “I will not allow the executive which I lead to transgress the province of the other two arms. I intend to fully continue respecting that sacred separation.”

Of course that does not bear the slightest suspicion that the country’s leadership makes unintelligent decisions that has the facade of uprightness. Actually, it’s just as important to being lucky fools of deception.

Therefore, how can one trust Prime Minister Anthony’s administration akin to backward leftist political and economic model of blind optimism and portray respectability, amidst mounting legal perils?

But, bear with me to understand predictable ineptitude from senior government ministers’ selective intelligence.

Minister for Legal Affairs, Home Affairs and National Security, Victor Phillip La Corbiniere, calls the speculation surrounding the perceived expedited court hearing of a foreigner “distasteful”, laying claims that there were very few instances where the deficiencies in the judiciary protracted the defendant’s time as a remand prisoner at Bordelais Correctional Facility, denying claims of preferential treatment.

Philip J. Pierre, minister responsible for infrastructure, port services and transport, has shrugged off suggestions that preferential treatment has been shown to a French national.

From end to end the candour implied is more of an illusion to a bona fide application of a ”French kiss”!

The struggle for Prime Minister Anthony’s weak administration is to rationalize how best to position the pathogens of deception. But ironically, it is intolerable to operate from a position of weakness. It serves no good to anyone learning to cope through humiliation and false expectations, this can only breed more unhappiness.

So, again, turning to the issues confronting a broken justice system, the pathogens of deception and the paralysis of fear gripping the country, citizens must demand social, economic and judicial reform. Prime Minister Anthony’s doggedness to reject citizens’ endorsement to constitutional reform signals business as usual for his administration’s phantom philosophy and inability to walk the talk.

In today’s political environment, jam-packed with common talking heads and the usual suspects, the greater need is to attain political awareness to counter abstract thought and sustained willpower to reverse the miserable affairs of state. Yes, there is hope to correct and guide the path forward, but the impulsiveness for a revolution must be one of brains and ballots, to win-over the current direction the country is heading.

Moreover, on the road to transform Saint Lucia, the disconcerting progress in mediocrity that is bound to the status quo must end; in order to keep citizens free form the prison of the past and the privileges bestowed on pathogens in the system of governance.

Indeed, dwindling funds have strained programmes and cutbacks to technical support have caused a split in the application of resources. However, this is due in part to a revenue problem and the non existence of a sensible economic plan.

All of which brings into question, how much the country’s leadership understands the odds to succeed in a system that slices and dices, misdiagnoses and botches solutions. And if, according to the political rhetoric, this election is about defining the future, then how can one be 100% Saint Lucian when government is incapable of defending rights and freedoms, economic well-being, equal opportunity with the dispensation of “selective” rule of law.

Human rights activist and attorney at law, Mary Francis, has acknowledged that “jail inmates need a champion to expedite their matters and to have the same clout as Sommer, maybe that’s how you get justice in this place [Saint Lucia]. You must have somebody of consequence behind you.”

The nature of this compounds the visible odds that are not favourable to the moral outcry for justice in Saint Lucia. The nexus comes into focus in the French Embassy’s statement that perhaps wraps up all complexities and uncertainties.

“After four years, the Sommer case is closed. The trial, which was anticipated by the French authorities, at the highest levels, was finally held and led to the release of Eric Sommer. Mr Sommer left Saint Lucia that night.”

Constitutional lawyer, Martinus Francois, says: “Time served is outrageous. Our own people have been languishing on remand for umpteen years without any mercy, without any caring on the part of the authorities, adding that the situation was disgraceful. The justice system here will lose all credibility in the eyes of the people.”

In view of that, it is tough not to be guarded against injustice, trauma and misery. And so, it is important to remind the leftist political class that the inflated grandeur of epistemic arrogance constrains human ingenuity and imagination.

And if such backward course of action continues, this will lead to an extended period of socio-economic mayhem, judicial injustice and distress with the trappings to make the country more ideologically bankrupt and frantic than present.

(Melanius Alphonse is a management and development consultant. He is an advocate for community development, social justice, economic freedom and equality. He can be reached at: malphonse@rogers.com)


  1. You are a good man and I would like to have some one like you on a good Team.
    I think you feel comfortable with a third (failed) Party but you are your own man
    and I’m not the type of guy to force my wishes on a grown man. But I would ask
    one thing of you, sir, if you are competing for the Soufriere seat, do me a favour
    go after Dalson, and beat the living sh**t out of him for Soufriere’s sake. This guy
    has no place in The St.Lucia Government. Weed him out, Soufriere deserves better.

  2. “REVENGE is mine p SAITH the LORD”
    Recite 1000 x per day
    PENANCE for:
    Peter Judas Josie AKA Goebbels @ Nazi Gestapo Dept of Flambeau & Chas Inc.

  3. /


    Why would any Lucian be so inundated with self-hatred, that he Hates the Slayer of Goliath? My Cousin Dalson has been one of the best politicians in Lucia, defeating that ignorant charlatan Allen Chastanet, thereby sparing Lucians the embarrassment of an Allen Chastanet in Government. Yet zombies like FOX hate Lucians so much, that you would love nothing more than the removal of my cousin from office because he speaks like a Lucian? you must be a rabid FOX in need of euthanasia or a cage!

  4. S.O.M…….I knew all along I was dealing with one whose mind is as warped as a fart in a
    Fan Factory. So you are related to Dalson, a great credential on your part my dear boy.
    If I were you, I would be hesitant in telling anyone. You know, just this morning I was figuring out who in both major Parties are really deserving of representing St.Lucia abroad. Among the UWP, I came up with 5. For Labour I got 4. But in that 4 we have Hilaire and I have great doubt about (1) winning and (2) about certain matters I rather not discuss.
    All of the others In both parties I dismiss as useless. Labour’s Rep at Chouisel should be
    fired forthwith for his incompetence, etc. What has Dalson done for poor Soufriere lately?

  5. Fox:

    There was a self-hating Negro living in his sister’s basement in New York City, who thought that this Racist and Sexist Naked White man, nailed to a crosspost was his God and Master. This Sexist Naked Satanic symbol of white supremacy, hated women so much that he placed an everlasting curse upon the female, claiming that it was because she was snaked by Lucifer in the Gardens, that caused man to die. In other words, our beloved George Odlum would still be alive if it were not for these “EVIL WOMEN”. So because of these Evil women, the Negro UNCLE TOM TOM succumbed to asphyxiation in a fire that trapped him in his sister’s basement.

    Now there are many other Self-hating Negroes, who exhibit identical traits like the now deceased UNCLE TOM. We have Negroes like Black Josie, John Wayne, and others who think the Caucasian is God Almighty. One Christian who hates women and imagines himself to be some kind of nemesis is THE VIRGIL; an otherwise decent Negro, save for his worship of Satan as his Master, and has devoted his life to making the nincompoop Allen Chastanet his God incarnate.

    Women are being raped because God cursed them, placing a CROSS ON THEIR BELLIES to have them suffer and die during gestation. This Negro THE VIRGIL, like you, THE FOX think that the idiot Allen Chastanet who was so rejected and humiliated by the people of my family’s birthplace, will tell his Father God to save the Black Christians from hating themselves, and stop the rape, and the fratricide.


    21. Stumble not at the beauty of a woman, and desire her not for pleasure.

    22. A woman, if she maintain her husband, is full of anger, impudence, and much reproach.

    23. A wicked woman abateth the courage, maketh an heavy countenance and a wounded heart: a woman that will not comfort her husband in distress maketh weak hands and feeble knees.

    24. Of the woman came the beginning of sin, and through her we all die.

  6. /


    Why was God so hurt by what satan did to the Woman in Eden ? Most men will forget being HORNED, and move on with their lives, but God NEVER FORGAVE Eve. Would you have forgiven her or put an everlasting curse on her if it was you woman that “Majee Noir” put that BIG SNAKE ON? I have a picture of Lucifer, so you decide.




  7. /


    Now remember that Lucifer Satan was called Child of the Morning Light? He was a Caucasian, so-called white man, but after horning God and snaking Eve, he was turned black like in the pic above, that’s why you black Negroes like Black Josie and Black John Wayne hate yourselves so much. Here’s a picture of Lucifer before he had sex with the “Evil Woman”, and made sin enter the world by ejaculatin in her. God never got over that HORN,and curse ALL WOMEN FOREVER AND EVER – it is called the Original Sin.






Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *