Letters & Opinion

Tourism: Bounty for the privileged?

Image of cruise ships in Castries Harbour
Image of Carlton Ishmael
By Carlton Ishmael

THE number one industry on the island is a Cash Cow for those who already have, while the nationals wait for the crumbs to sustain themselves from it.

It starts with the head taxes and the environmental tax and the expected taxes that the state is supposed to benefit and profit from the hotel owners who have been given generous incentives to build on the island.

The cruise ship profits the most, because the disembarking passengers who do land-based tours have to pay a hefty mark-up on all the acknowledged tours, the tour agents fall next in line, then the suppliers and the sites that are controlled, either by the state, (such as the Sulphur Springs) or private enterprise (such as the botanical gardens), some eating establishments, a few private taxis — and last on the list is the occasional vendor.

The tourists who choose not to go on an organised tour try to browse through the city centre to possibly do a little souvenir buying, or go to the next best place — the Beach –and make sure that they are back on board the ship for their prepaid lunch.

The natives, struggle, beg, try to outsmart the visitors into buying some things, often being referred to as harassers, and they are usually told that ‘We have already purchased that item in the last island we visited’, or ‘It’s too expensive’, or they will only settle for a local beer.

The business only happens in selective areas because the island is supposedly unsafe and crime is rampant.

There are no established entertainment or eating outlets to sample our national dishes, or sample our coconut water or mangoes, no medical items or spices that are original, no brand-made clothing or art galleries that are reasonably priced.

In fact, the tourism authorities have not made the masses part of that industry. It is by luck and chance that we gain some profits, yet every season you hear how great a season we had.

The hotels encourage their guests to dine indoors, in fact the new trend and type of resorts are all-inclusive, competing with all other private tourism related investment. So the streets are empty, even in Rodney Bay and the restaurants are empty and the locals dine occasionally — and the struggle continues.

No body speaks out, nobody tells about the horrors of owning a business, or how hard it is to keep people employed. Yet you hear daily about new touristic ventures coming on steam.

Well, I must be blind or living in another country because tourism in this country is about those who have or are rubbing shoulders with the government.

The standard requirements are stringent, insurance policies are high, licenses are not easy to come by, and the mingle of tourist and locals only happens at Gros Islet on a Friday night, or maybe Anse la Raye or Marigot occasionally.

This industry needs to be revamped, revisited, and reorganised, for now it is not serving the needs of our people.

The people have to become more self-reliant, we have to grow in confidence, become creative, bold and adventurous, but that can only happen if the state changes their way of doing business.

We see the changes worldwide, we know how competitive this industry is, we pay huge salaries for those who mind the industry, yet our returns are minimal — and we live on in hope while we build new airports and seaports and talk about promoting a better life for our people.

It’s as if we accept that: C’est la vie!


  1. Carlton, I still don’t know what the heck you’re gripping about. If you don’t
    like it, would you prefer to go back forty five years ago when bananas was
    the cash cow? who was it that benefited, was it the hard working farmers
    or the lazy good for nothing beggars. What you ‘ve described is actually the same
    all over the Caribbean and I’ve been there and seen that. St. Lucia is still the best.

  2. So easy to criticize and to be critical but it don’t see your solutions or what you are doing to make it better.
    I am a tourist who has been coming to the island for 50+ years and I have seen incredible improvement all over the island. Is it perfect, no but no where is. Look at the USA, utter turmoil as also in the UK.
    I see progress, I see families doing better, I see children getting a better education and I see people being successful. Yes, some are doing better than other but like any where in the world, hard work, honesty and a pure heart and a grateful spirit go a long way in making ones life better.
    I will continue to support St. Lucia and businesses and local people who continue to also contribute to the growth and success of your island.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.